Skip to main content
Community Outreach Services

Resource guide: What to do after a failed or refused DOT drug or alcohol test

A plain language walk through the federal return-to-duty process, one step at a time, with the rule text behind every step so you can check it yourself.

Last reviewed against the rule text on .

The short version

  • You are removed from safety-sensitive duties immediately and cannot work them for any DOT employer until you finish the process.
  • Your employer must give you a list of SAPs, free of charge.
  • The order is: SAP evaluation, recommended education or treatment, a second evaluation, a negative return-to-duty test, then unannounced follow-up tests.
  • Getting your job back is your employer's decision, not the SAP's.

You are taken off safety-sensitive duties right away

When a drug test is verified positive, an alcohol test shows a concentration of 0.04 or higher, or you refuse to test, your employer must immediately remove you from performing safety-sensitive functions. An adulterated or substituted specimen counts as a refusal.

You cannot go back until you successfully complete the return-to-duty process, which the next sections describe.

Rule text: 49 CFR 40.23 (opens the eCFR in a new tab)

The bar follows you to any DOT employer

Until you complete the Substance Abuse Professional (SAP) process, you cannot perform DOT safety-sensitive duties for any employer, not only the one who ordered the test. This applies after a verified positive, an alcohol result of 0.04 or higher, a refusal to test, or any other violation of a DOT drug or alcohol prohibition.

Rule text: 49 CFR 40.285 (opens the eCFR in a new tab)

Your employer must give you a list of SAPs

Your employer must give you a list of SAPs who are readily available to you and acceptable to the employer, with names, addresses and telephone numbers. The employer cannot charge you a fee for putting that list together or giving it to you.

Dr. Nettles is a DOT-qualified SAP who conducts SAP evaluations himself.

Rule text: 49 CFR 40.287 (opens the eCFR in a new tab)

The SAP evaluates you and recommends education or treatment

The SAP makes a clinical assessment, then recommends a course of education, treatment or both that you must complete before you return to safety-sensitive duties. The recommendation is an individualized plan, and the SAP sends a written report directly to your employer's designated employer representative.

The initial evaluation may be face to face or remote, using real time audio and video.

Rule text: 49 CFR 40.291 (opens the eCFR in a new tab), 49 CFR 40.293 (opens the eCFR in a new tab)

Who pays is not set by DOT

Your employer is not required to provide the SAP evaluation or any education or treatment the SAP recommends. The rule leaves payment for employers and employees to decide, and it may be governed by existing management and labor agreements and health care benefits. Ask your employer, your union and your insurer before you schedule.

Rule text: 49 CFR 40.289 (opens the eCFR in a new tab)

One SAP, and nobody can change the recommendation

You must not seek a second SAP's evaluation, and your employer must not either or rely on one. No one may change the SAP's evaluation or recommendations in any way. Only the original SAP can modify them, and only based on new information.

Rule text: 49 CFR 40.295 (opens the eCFR in a new tab), 49 CFR 40.297 (opens the eCFR in a new tab)

The SAP re-evaluates you after you finish

When you have carried out the recommendations, the SAP evaluates you again to decide whether you complied. The SAP reports the result in writing to your employer's designated representative.

If the SAP reports that you did not comply, your employer must not return you to safety-sensitive duties. The SAP can find that you complied before every part of treatment is finished.

Rule text: 49 CFR 40.301 (opens the eCFR in a new tab)

The return-to-duty test must be negative

The return-to-duty test cannot happen until the SAP has decided you complied. The result must be a negative drug test, an alcohol test with a concentration below 0.02, or both, depending on your violation.

Passing does not guarantee your job back. Your employer is not required to return you to safety-sensitive duties because you met these conditions, and that is a personnel decision. The SAP also does not decide whether you are fit for duty unless a DOT agency rule requires it.

Rule text: 49 CFR 40.305 (opens the eCFR in a new tab)

Then follow-up testing, unannounced

After finding that you complied, the SAP writes a follow-up testing plan. At a minimum it includes six unannounced tests in the first 12 months, and the SAP may require tests during the following 48 months. The SAP decides how many tests there are, how often, and whether they are for drugs, alcohol or both, unless a DOT agency rule says otherwise.

Your employer chooses the dates, you are not told the schedule in advance, and the plan follows you to later employers and through breaks in service.

Rule text: 49 CFR 40.307 (opens the eCFR in a new tab), 49 CFR 40.309 (opens the eCFR in a new tab)

Commercial drivers: the Clearinghouse

Drivers who hold a commercial driver's license are also covered by the FMCSA Drug and Alcohol Clearinghouse. The SAP must report to the Clearinghouse the date of the initial assessment and the date you were found compliant and eligible for return-to-duty testing, by the close of the next business day.

Your employer reports a negative return-to-duty result and the completion of follow-up tests. Your “prohibited” status ends when you complete the SAP process, get a negative return-to-duty result, and complete the follow-up plan. For the Clearinghouse's own instructions, use FMCSA's Clearinghouse site (opens in a new tab).

Rule text: 49 CFR 382.701 (opens the eCFR in a new tab), 49 CFR 382.705 (opens the eCFR in a new tab)

Please read this

This guide follows the common rules in 49 CFR Part 40. Each DOT agency, such as the FAA, FMCSA, FRA, FTA, PHMSA and the Coast Guard, has its own rules that can add to them, and some details differ by mode.

It is general information, not legal advice, and it is not a substitute for your employer's policy or your union or attorney. Call our office with your questions.

Ready to start with a SAP evaluation?

Call our office. Dr. Nettles conducts every SAP evaluation himself and will walk you through step one.